Project Gutenberg is a massive digital library of public domain works. Its archives contain not merely novels, but also numerous short stories from magazines with adjectives like “Amazing”, “Thrilling”, “Startling” and “Wondrous” in their titles. I’m making my way through its vast catalogue of these speculative fiction works. Today, I’ll be looking at “The Thing in the Attic” by James Blish, published in If Worlds of Science Fiction in 1954.
Gutenberg Link
SPOILERS BELOW
“The Thing in the Attic” is about some tailed hominids which live in the treetops of an inhospitable jungle. The protagonists are cast out of society and exiled to the ground for the crime of blasphemy because they doubt the tribe’s religious scripture. They struggle to survive life on the ground for a while until they randomly blunder into some humans, who reveal that they seeded the hominids on this world as part of a colonization effort and are just pleased as punch that some have finally adjusted to living on the ground (and never mind all the other thought-criminals before them for whom exile proved fatal).
This story was actually a somewhat compelling survival narrative until the ending came along and ruined it. The sudden appearance of the humans to bring the narrative to a close smacks of deus ex machina, and their blithe unconcern about having created a murderous theocracy does them no favors. And just what does the title have to do with the story, anyway?
Final Rating: 2/5