The angels are calling out your name across the light and its refrain. And the devil knows which names to call. He’s been calling all night long. And the witch’s hammer is on the floor. And the devil won’t speak to you no more. And even though you’d spit upon my grave, I love, love, love, love, love you all the same. Let’s smash Witch Hammer, by Cullen Bunn and Dalibor Talajić.
Synopsis:
AFTERSHOCK ORIGINAL GRAPHIC NOVEL! Witch. The word conjures images of hags in black robes and crooked hats, standing over cauldrons of bubbling brew. But witches are among us, and we do not realize it. They are our friends and neighbors. They are our family members. They are our idols.
And someone is murdering them.
A killer is stalking witches, hunting them down mercilessly. Agents Frontenac and Guinness are on the killer’s trail. But as they delve deeper into the hidden, magical world around them, they are haunted by a terrifying question. Is the killer doing the right thing?
Source: Goodreads
SPOILERS BELOW
In Witch Hammer, a man in a ram mask is going on a murder spree, and FBI special agents Frontenac and Guinness are working to track him down. They discover that he is a former member of a cult that worshipped the demon Leviathan, now seeking vengeance against the other members of his order after they sacrificed his children. When it becomes clear that there is more than religious fanaticism at play, that actual supernatural forces are at war, how will they fight for justice as mere mortals caught between the divine and the infernal?
Turns out, they won’t. They just give up on stopping the killer and sit on the sidelines while he wipes out the rest of the cult. Wow, that was disappointing.
The structure of this comic just absolutely does not work. Just who the hell is our protagonist supposed to be? My first thought is that it’s Frotnenac and Guinness, since they’re the ones working to track down the killer and unravel the mystery of the cult. But if so, they’re pretty shit protagonists, because they don’t do any protaging. They never really manage to catch up to the killer, and give up the case once it becomes apparent that it’s supernatural. Then is the killer, Jacob, supposed to be the protagonist? He’s not a very good one either. His first introduction is murdering a bunch of teen girls like a slasher movie villain. Oh, but he has a literal angel on his side, so I guess he’s supposed to be morally in the right? Except having all-seeing, all-knowing, all-powerful, all-benevolent Supreme Being in your corner kind of takes the tension out of proceedings – he slaughters his way through cultists like an unstoppable juggernaut, meeting not even the slightest resistance, as narration captions confirm that Leviathan and its followers are helpless against him because the power of God is stronger than the power of the Devil. His quest for vengeance has all the nail-biting suspense of shooting fish in a barrel, is what I’m saying. And then at the end the angel who was helping him turns on him and fries him as well, saying that he isn’t forgiven for his own time spent in the cult before turning against them, so I guess we weren’t supposed to be rooting for him after all? Useless detectives, evil but helpless cultists, boring unstoppable and still apparently evil killer…. all the characters in this story suck. I can’t care about what’s going on when I don’t care about any of the people who are doing it or having it done to them.
I didn’t enjoy Witch Hammer.
Final Rating: 2/5